| Surname | Data | Member # |
| DALY | Utica, NY; Canada; England; Ireland | O070 |
| DALY | Oswego, NY | E111 |
| DANN | NY; Holland | A173 |
| DANN | Oswego Co., NY | K137 |
| DAVENPORT | Yates Co., NY | T153 |
| DAVIS / DUNHAM | Ontario Co., NY | M337 |
| DEAN | Canaan, CT | R159 |
| DECKER | Broome Co., NY | M508 |
| DEFOREST | Cayuga Co., NY | M521 |
| DEGROAT | Stony Point, Rockland Co., NY | E097 |
| DEGROAT | Stony Point, Rockland Co., NY | N097 |
| DELAMATER | Dutchess & Madison Co., NY | W382 |
| DENNEY | Ontario Co., NY | L226 |
| DENSE | Yates Co., NY | T153 |
| DEWEY | Washington County, NY | R247 |
| DEWITT / DEWIT | Syracuse, Onondaga Co., NY; Kings Co, NY; ME | S618 |
| DEY | Middlesex Co., NJ; Allegany Co., NY; Venango Co., PA | C372 |
| DICE | Central NY; Germany | D257 |
| DICE | Onondaga Co., NY | D257 |
| DICK | Syracuse, NY; Bavaria, Germany | R270 |
| DICKINSON | Cortland, NY | D092 |
| DIEL | Rochester, Syracuse & Utica, NY | B260 |
| DIFABIO | Onondaga & Wayne Co., NY; Western, NY | J135 |
| DILLON | Co. Kerry, Ireland; Syracuse, NY | B517 |
| DIRLAM | PA | B431 |
| DITTRICH | Queens, NY | D224 |
| DODGE | Colchester, CT; Cortland Co., NY | M481 |
| DONEGAN | Canada; Syracuse & New York City, NY | B461 |
| DONOVAN | Madison Co., NY; Ireland | B574 |
| DORWARD, James | Truxton, Cortland Co., NY | T159 |
| DOYLE | Angola, Clyde & Syracuse, NY | K145 |
| DRISKO | Onondaga Co., NY; New England | H416 |
| DUNHAM | Seneca & Tompkins Co., NY | M337 |
| DUNHAM | RI; Herkimer Co., NY; Scriba, NY | B449 |
| DUNHAM | NY | B474 |
| DUNLAP | Sandy Creek, Richland & Albion, NY | D302 |
| DURNAN / DURNIN | North Lawrence, NY | P221 |
| EATON | Chester & Warren, NY | E110 |
| EDES/EADES | Verona, Oneida Co., NY | E031 |
| EDGET | Yates & Stuben Co., NY | H398 |
| EDWARDS | Albany, NY; Delhi, NY; Jefferson Co., NY | P249 |
| EGAN | Cooperstown area / Otsego County, NY | G282 |
| EGGER | Westernville, Lee & Taberg, Oneida Co., NY | H394 |
| EGGERS | The Netherlands; Oneida Co., NY; MI | G257 |
| EGGLESTON | Cayuga & Washington Co., NY; MA | E107 |
| EITAPENCE / EIDEBENZ | Darmstad, Germany; Utica & Binghamton, NY | B405 |
| ELLIS | Tompkins Co., NY | M337 |
| ELLIS | DeRuyter, NY; W. Greenwich, RI | N-110 |
| ELLSWORTH | NH; Truxton, Cortland Co., NY; MI | C365 |
| ELLSWORTH | NY | W209 |
| ELSASSER | Germany; Syracuse, NY | W336 |
| ELWELL | Dutchess, Monroe & Cattaraugus Co., NY | H398 |
| ELY | Jefferson & Greene Co., NY | R046 |
| EMERSON | Wayne & Onondaga Co., NY; MA | S178 |
| EMMONS | NY; IL | S597 |
| EMMONS | Washington County, NY | R247 |
| ENGEL | Buffalo, Erie Co., NY | W429 |
| ERWIN | Franklin & Onondaga Co., NY | G280 |
| EUSTIS | St. Lawrence Co. & Onondaga Co., NY | E109 |
| EVANS | Peterboro, Madison Co., NY; Tyre, Seneca Co., NY | K158 |
| EVARTS | Washington & Warren Co., NY | M447 |
| EVERETT | CT; Delaware & Cortland Co., NY | S534 |
| FAIRBANK(S) | Morrisville, Madison Co., NY; Otsego Co., NY; Deansboro, Oneida Co., NY | H394 |
| FANCHER, Smith | Sanford, Broome Co., NY | B569 |
| FARNHAM | Forestville, Chautauqua Co., NY | B548 |
| FAULK, Frank | Fenton, Broome Co., NY | T159 |
| FELLOWS | Syracuse, NY; DeRuyter, NY; Canaan, CT | N-110 |
| FERGUSON | CT; Brooklyn & Kings, NY | C365 |
| FERGUSON | Barker & Castle Creek, Broome Co., NY | F201 |
| FERGUSON | Ontario Co., NY | C477 |
| FERRIS | Dutchess & Otsego Co., NY | N106 |
| FIFE | Canada; Scotland; Onondaga Co., NY | M481 |
| FIJALKOVICH / FIALKOVIC | Jastrabie, Slovakia; Bridgeport, CT; Syracuse, NY | R254 |
| FILLMORE | MA; CT; Middletown, VT; Jefferson Co., NY | B462 |
| FINKLER | Germany; Syracuse, NY | S541 |
| FISH | VT: Whitehall, Washington Co., NY | C365 |
| FISH | Herkimer Co., NY; Clyde, Wayne Co., NY; Brooklyn, NY | N093 |
| FISHER | Willsboro, Essex Co., NY | D146 |
| FITCH | Oneida, NY | B197 |
| FITCH | Jefferson Co., NY | W405 |
| FIX | Onondaga Co., NY; Naumburg, Germany | R270 |
| FLETCHER | Cooperstown, NY; Madison Co., NY; Springville, PA | B227 |
| FOLEY | Lancaster, Erie Co., NY | T153 |
| FOOTE | NY (Southern Tier); PA (Northern) | D257 |
| FOOTE | Souther Tier, NY | D257 |
| FOOTE | Sharon, Litchfield Co., CT; Berkshire Co., MA; Saratoga Co., NY | T134 |
| FOSTER | Oswego Co., NY | H203 |
| FOWLSTON | German & Smithville, Chenango Co., NY; Willett, Cortland Co., NY | F206 |
| FRANCE | Seward & Oswego, NY; Richmond, IN | K154 |
| FRANKLIN | Prattsburgh & Wheeler, Steuben Co., NY; Mansfield, Cattaraugus Co., NY | D205 |
| FRECHOFF | Syracuse, NY | R270 |
| FREEMAN | Oneonta, NY; Springville, PA | B227 |
| FREEMAN | Washington Co., NY | R247 |
| FRINK | NY | F201 |
| FULLER | Oswego & Oneida Co., NY | C334 |
| FULLER | St. Lawrence Co., NY; VT | D146 |
| FULLMER | Seneca Co., NY | T153 |
| GALE | Binghamton, Broome Co., NY | B545 |
| GARDINER | Gloversville, NY | S600 |
| GARLOCK | Montgomery & Herkimer Co., NY | B315 |
| GATCHELL | New England; NY; PA | R046 |
| GAY | Jamesville & Pompey, Onondaga County, NY | G282 |
| GEHRING | Germany; Syracuse, NY | S541 |
| GEOPATTON | Troy, NY | P195 |
| GERLING | Utica, NY | O070 |
| GIARROSSO | Onondaga & Wayne Co., NY; Western, NY | J135 |
| GIBBS | NY | S597 |
| GIFFORD | Oneida Co., NY | J069 |
| GILL | Jefferson & Oswego Co., NY | H203 |
| GILMORE | Cayuga Co., NY | G100 |
| GIRVAN | Utica, NY; Ireland; Scotland | O070 |
| GLEASON | Fulton, NY; Ireland | F218 |
| GODFREY | Jefferson Co., NY; VT | G252 |
| GOODRICH | Cattaraugus Co., NY | A150 |
| GORMAN | Co. Ross Common Ireland; Williamstown, NY | B461 |
| GORTON | Troy & Newburg, NY | P195 |
| GOSLOWSKI | Syracuse, Onondaga Co., NY | A158 |
| GOSS | Cayuga & Oswego Co., NY | B474 |
| GOULD | Washington & Cayuga Co., NY; MI | W362 |
| GRAHAM | Co. Antrim, Ireland; Onondaga Co., NY | J127 |
| GRANGER | Cherry Valley, NY; Roseboom, NY; Suffield, CT | B227 |
| GRIFFES / GRIFFIS | Onondaga, Cayuga & Stuben Co., NY | W362 |
| GRIFFIN | Moira, Franklin Co., NY; Addison Co., VT; Killingworth, CT | L181 |
| GRIGGS | Keene, NH; Newfane, VT; Montgomery & Seneca Co., NY | B512 |
| GRIPPIN | Columbia & Broome Co., NY | R275 |
| GRUMBACH | Germany; Syracuse, NY | W336 |
| GUILFOYLE | Syracuse, NY; Punxatawney, PA; Ireland | D092 |
| GUSTKE | Liverpool, NY; Germany | F218 |
| GUY | Kingsbury, NY; MA; Washington Co., NY | M340 |
| GWYN | England; Oswego Co., NY; Cleveland, NY; Detroit, MI | K137 |